Forget the glitter and sequins of the 2000s. The November 2010 fashion editorial was titled “What to Wear When the World Ends (2012 is Coming).” Styled with plaid flannels, combat boots, and repurposed military jackets, the spread directly predicted the “grunge revival” and the rise of thrift-core. Models posed holding defunct flip phones and paperback copies of The Hunger Games (published just two months earlier). The tagline: “You can’t trust the economy, but you can trust a good pair of broken-in Doc Martens.”

This issue is now frequently cited in retrospectives on digital culture because of its prescient tech column. While other magazines marveled at the just-released iPhone 4’s Retina display, 18 Eighteen ran a darkly humorous piece on the anxiety of the “blue bubble.” In November 2010, BBM (BlackBerry Messenger) was still the status symbol for teens, and the article warned: “When your ‘delivered’ checkmark turns to a ‘read’ and two hours pass without a reply, you are not being chill. You are being surveilled by your own loneliness.”

In the end, 18 Eighteen folded in 2012, a casualty of the very digital wave it had tried to critique. But the November 2010 issue remains a time capsule: a reminder that sometimes, the most important stories aren’t about what’s new, but about what’s true.